Hydrogenation using (Ph3P)3RhCl - Wilkinson's catalyst

(Ph3P)3RhCl, which is generally known as Wilkinson's catalyst, acts as a homogeneous catalyst for the hydrogenation of alkenes and alkynes. It does not catalyse the reduction of other organic functional groups, although it is a reactive compound and does react with many organic and inorganic reagents. (Ph3P)3RhCl is know to slightly dissociated (about 5%) into the 14e-electron species (Ph3P)2RhCl and PPh3 in pure solvents of low coordinating power (eg: in benzene). (Ph3P)2RhCl is thought to pick up solvent to generate (Ph3P)2RhCl(S) which undergoes a series of oxidative addition and elimination reactions and the equilibrium is displaced.
(Reference 3)


R. Tolman has articulated a rule that seems to govern all transition-metal-mediated catalytic processes:

(Reference 6)


This image describes the Wilkinson's catalytic cycle. Every 15 seconds the next step will be shown.


NB: This is not the only cycle that can be drawn. Some scientists found a five coordinate species [A]: (Ph3P)2RhCl(H2) and proposed an alternative cycle.

Question: Complete the alternative catalytical cycle by yourself, and have a look if you are right.

[A] [A]